View Single Post
  #1  
04-11-2011
rohitbd
Member
 
: Apr 2011
: Mumbai
: 48
:
: 36 | 0.01 Per Day
Will Lokpal solve our troubles?

Sorry for the rather negative sounding title...of course I have no doubt that it will change things for the better. The question is by what quantum? In my humble opinion, this alone will not root out corruption completely (or to the level where it no longer affects us) - there have to be other, radical changes too. Like our "system". For one, our lawmakers do not have any one (other than the opposition) to control them. And why will they (and the opposition) change something that benefits them? There is absolutely no reason. The only thing that counts is getting a majority of votes to come into power - and then you can spend the next five years doing what you want - no one can question you!!

How many times have we heard of people speaking out against the local corporator or the powerful businessman or the powerful neta, getting killed? Do we have to "search" for any such instance? No. Its there, in full and shameless public view - those in power or with connections subverting others' liberties. Yes, when someone says "do you know who I am, do you know what I can do to you" - he or she is subverting the other person's liberty - and in essence our country's constitution which guarantees us freedom of liberty and speech.

Spare a thought for the numerous defence personnel spending their days away from home & family protecting what we call our country's freedom - freedom which many a corrupt, power-hungry people use to literally lay bare and naked this country's dignity.

The police who are controlled by the local corporator or the state govt. who has to dance to their tune simply because their jobs are at stake. Why should a police officer, whose papers can be transferred at the whim of such a govt. or person, not obey if his/her job is at stake? This is the another problem we need to solve - how to let the police do their jobs without political interference? Can we have a system where the police can do their job well? The current system is simply a tool in the hands of the administration to use the police more for themselves than for the public. Consider this: In the event of a civil agitation where people have simply gone against the administration, on whose side do you think the police will be? Even though each policeman is a citizen he/she will HAVE TO favour the administration - the administration is more important than the people.

The third problem is "democracy" - in particular the form practised here. You have a party that represents people - so far, so good. Then you have another, and another, and still another. What we have in effect is basically no longer people's representatives but parties who have supporters - so its only a show of strength as far as anything is concerned. Then is the system of funding these parties - you want to set up a big mall, pay up (i.e., to the party that holds sway in that area). Classic case is the builder-politician nexus. How do we solve this?

The point is, merely catching hold of govt. babus is not going to help in the bigger picture - we'll still have the problem of subversion of liberty by those in power. Till subversion exists, corruption will be there and vice-versa. Till this is overcome, we cannot consider India a truly free country.