India Against Corruption

Register

  India Against Corruption > INDIA AGAINST CORRUPTION > DISCUSSIONS > Opinion & POLLs
New Topics

Questions to Anna & his team

Is this the way of protesting asking your supporters to go to PM's house, approaching celebrities and forcing them to .....



7
  • 1 bharatwasi
  • 3 kohlinidhi8@gmail.com
  • 1 NCSinha
  • 1 Proud Indian
  • 1 Deepak4achieve


  #1  
08-25-2011
Junior Member
 
: Aug 2011
: India
:
: 19 | 0.00 Per Day
Questions to Anna & his team


Is this the way of protesting asking your supporters to go to PM's house, approaching celebrities and forcing them to support your movement?
To AK - After meeting he said that govt were listening to the team the previous day and yesterday they (govt) was talking and team Anna was listenting, You dont want to listen to the other party, who is arrogant here you or the govt? You cant be supreme than the parliament.
Why only Anna is fasting why not his core team members like AK, KB, PB?
In Ramlila grounds other than Anna everyone else are having food then what is wrong if PM hosts Iftar feast?
To those who are all supporting this movement, can you promise that you have not received or paid bribe for anything in your life till today and take oath that you will not pay or receive bribe in any form and stand by it?
Yesterday AK accused govt stating that they are planning to forcible remove Anna from Ramlila ground at around 2 am to 4 am why it didnt happen?Iinstead of mediator he will fit for the astrologer role better.

Last edited by vvsr; 08-26-2011 at 12:20 AM
  #2  
08-25-2011
Junior Member
 
: Aug 2011
: new delhi
: 70
:
: 1 | 0.00 Per Day

latest news at 6pm today, after meeting with PM, every body is asking for breaking the fast by ANNA after 10 days. This is definitely the need of the hour as ANNA's life & health is precious than the preciousest of thing on this universe today. As politicians are conversant to play "aankh micholi" like presenting not only jan lokpalbill but also aruna roy's+ JP's bill u/s 184. it appears they are diluting the issue and again gaining time. SO MY SUGGESTION IS THAT IN HINDU RELIGION FIGURE 11 IS CONSIDERED PIOUS AND NOT 10. SO WE SHOULD LEAVE IT TO ANNA FOR DECISION.
  #3  
08-25-2011
Junior Member
 
: Aug 2011
: Allahabad
: 35
:
: 15 | 0.00 Per Day

There is no time for ethics left in our country when it comes to politicians... When they were busy doing scams of worth 1,75,000 crores without any hesitation, then why should we think about right or wrong for them.. All is fair.. Moreover, these politicians should be thankful that they have to face GANDHIS till now.. Once the youth changes its face to BHAGAT SINGH.. saale jaan bachate firenge..

The point is not who is fasting and who is not.. The point is that is the purpose getting solved.. If every1 will start fasting who will work...

I believe whatever team ANNA is doing is far more better than what will happen if we still remain in the hands of our politicians...
  #4  
08-30-2011
Senior Member
 
: Aug 2011
: Kanpur UP
: 39
:
: 373 | 0.08 Per Day
A topic, must to discuss

Ye sahi hai ki neta apna kaam imaandari se ni krte hai lekin hum log bhi to aaj tak khamosh baithe kyo rahe lekin tab to sb ye sochte the ki main kyo baat karu lekin aaj waqt hai ki unke sath kadaa behave krne ki jst like BHAGAT SINGH JI tbhi unhe samjh me aayega
JAI HIND
  #5  
08-31-2011
Moderator
 
: Mar 2011
: Patna
: 73
:
: 219 | 0.05 Per Day
Cool There are no tether posts here

Is this the way of protesting asking your supporters to go to PM's house, approaching celebrities and forcing them to support your movement?
To AK - After meeting he said that govt were listening to the team the previous day and yesterday they (govt) was talking and team Anna was listenting, You dont want to listen to the other party, who is arrogant here you or the govt? You cant be supreme than the parliament.
Why only Anna is fasting why not his core team members like AK, KB, PB?
In Ramlila grounds other than Anna everyone else are having food then what is wrong if PM hosts Iftar feast?
To those who are all supporting this movement, can you promise that you have not received or paid bribe for anything in your life till today and take oath that you will not pay or receive bribe in any form and stand by it?
Yesterday AK accused govt stating that they are planning to forcible remove Anna from Ramlila ground at around 2 am to 4 am why it didnt happen?Iinstead of mediator he will fit for the astrologer role better.
Asking questions is a good thing if they are asked in a spirit of congeniality. These questions are asked for the sake of asking questions, not for eliciting desirable information. While it is open to debate whether this is the way to protest, there is no denying that this is one of the only ways to protest when people who are supposed to listen to your voice stop doing so and move into an ivory towers of their own. Govt. paid heed to Anna not because it is in agreement with everything Anna said. But that Anna said something that was being heard all over the world. Only the government seemed purblind and wanted to wriggle out of it by any means, mostly foul means. Even now when it has agreed to include those three sticky points, it did so grudgingly and given an opportunity it will try to wriggle out of it any moment. It would therefore be wrong to presume the government has given in. It simply buckled under pressure because this kind of pressure was never brought against it in the past. Blaming the members of civil society would not do simply because the society had opened itself to suggestions. Scores of people from all walks of life have contributed to the making of draft and fortunately those associated with the exercise have done an extensive research work before readying the draft. Those questioning people associated with it should take a look at various international laws and documents including UN Convention against Corruption to which India is also a signatory before coming to any conclusion. As for who is arrogant, there is little to doubt that this government has displayed arrogance of the worst kind. Any government formed by the elected representatives (Incidentally Dr. Manmohan Singh is not an elected representative--he has become a member of Rajya Sabha by swearing a false affidavit that he is a domiciled citizen of Guwahati where he did not live even for a day) should behave like a government in transit. A party comes to power on the basis of elections results. Elections are fought on manifestos they present at the time of elections. No party has ever declared its intent to enhance its pay and perks and to patronize corruption which this government has been doing with impunity. Despite protestations of all kinds including indictment by judiciary, press and public, the government arrogantly goes on doing what it is forewarned against. What remedy is left for the people to make this government see the reason if not go on fast like Anna did? We could not resort to this kind of movement because we did not have an Anna in our midst. You always need a clean man to launch this kind of movement because it requires moral force to do so and who if not Anna could have started this? But Anna has his limitations; and so, he chose the services of some qualified and committed people. These people are not doing anything on their own. They are goaded by Anna because Anna trusts them and their ability to help him realize his dream of doing something for the country. Why should any one question the motive of this movement?
  #6  
08-31-2011
Proud Indian's Avatar
Senior Member
 
: Feb 2011
: Chandigarh
:
: 312 | 0.06 Per Day

There is no time for ethics left in our country when it comes to politicians... When they were busy doing scams of worth 1,75,000 crores without any hesitation, then why should we think about right or wrong for them.. All is fair.. Moreover, these politicians should be thankful that they have to face GANDHIS till now.. Once the youth changes its face to BHAGAT SINGH.. saale jaan bachate firenge..

The point is not who is fasting and who is not.. The point is that is the purpose getting solved.. If every1 will start fasting who will work...

I believe whatever team ANNA is doing is far more better than what will happen if we still remain in the hands of our politicians...
well said .........thanks to Team Anna
  #7  
08-31-2011
Member
 
: Aug 2011
: Singheshwar
: 36
:
: 44 | 0.01 Per Day

ans. of your questions
Prgrph 1: yes, it is the way. Jab parliyament bahri ho to uske kan kholne k liye bomb v fekne padte hain. Aap ye na kahe ki aisa Bhagat Singh ne English govt. k liye kiya tha. Ha unhone English govt k liye aisa kiya tha. Antar kya hai dono me. Wo humara khun choos kar apna ghar bharte the ye apna bharte hain. Wo lala lajpat ray par ladthiya barsate hain ye hajaro so rahe logo par.
Prgrph 2: ofcourse perticular A K isn't supream than parliyament, but people are. And another answer u have already taken that if every1 do fast then who will work?
Prgrph 3: yes i could. If u need any proof come to people near me and ask about my charecter.
Prgrph 4: govt. did it with swami ramdev that's why not only AK but we also have doubt that it will be reapeated. May be anyone said false to AK, may be govt. changed its plan on time
  #8  
10-10-2011
Junior Member
 
: Sep 2011
: baripada,orissa
: 76
:
: 12 | 0.00 Per Day

dear Sir,

Replying to the thread I am to say that before we decide to take any action,we should first form one common public platform allowing wide possible opportunities to all and one interested,able, honest foresighted people and consider their suggestions opinions etc in possible detail to take further action.
Now first one organisation first start and branches throughout country may be started. A preliminary constitution and guide lines etc.may be recorded.The phone no. and email address etc. known to each other to contact and talk among themselves.The leadership better may be taken by "India against corruption" organisation. In this regard specific suggestions may be invited from all interested person and be considered properly to form a solid Organisation first to follow further action.
I am Ramachandra Mohanty, male 65, from Orissa,B.A. Retd.govt.servant. My email is "rcm_999@rediffmail.com" and "rcm999@sify.com"
Thanking You
Yuors faithfully
Ramachandra.
Replying to the thread I am to say that before we decide to take any action,we should first form one common public platform allowing wide possible opportunities to all and one interested,able, honest foresighted people and consider their suggestions opinions etc in possible detail to take further action.
Now first one organisation first start and branches throughout country may be started. A preliminary constitution and guide lines etc.may be recorded.The phone no. and email address etc. known to each other to contact and talk among themselves.The leadership better may be taken by "India against corruption" organisation. In this regard specific suggestions may be invited from all interested person and be considered properly to form a solid Organisation first to follow further action.
I am Ramachandra Mohanty, male 65, from Orissa,B.A. Retd.govt.servant. My email is "rcm_999@rediffmail.com" and "rcm999@sify.com"
Thanking You
Yuors faithfully
Ramachandra.

 




India Against Corruption
India Against Corruption is a PUBLIC Forum, NOT associated with any organisation(s).
DISCLAIMER: Members of public post content on this website. We hold no responsibility for the same. However, abuse may be reported to us.

Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0