India Against Corruption

Register

  India Against Corruption > INDIA AGAINST CORRUPTION > Starters > Members Forum

"Reservation is one of the root cause of corruption and governmet failure".

Gentle men ! "Healthy percentage of sc/st, obc group was demanded in Jan lokpal team but why the (Mr. Sangma) .....



25


  #101  
07-25-2012
Senior Member
 
: Apr 2011
: gwalior
: 53
:
: 711 | 0.18 Per Day
"sc/st support"


Gentle men ! "Healthy percentage of sc/st, obc group was demanded in Jan lokpal team but why the (Mr. Sangma) is not being elected for the president of India."
Reply With Quote
  #102  
08-02-2012
Junior Member
 
: Aug 2012
: MAHARASHTRA
: 74
:
: 4 | 0.00 Per Day

India has been saddled with corruption ever since it attained independence; now it has crept into every vital of the country. It is high time that we should uproot corruption and throw it out like we did in the case of the british. Let us strive hard with dedication and devotion to uproot corruption,foreigner's rule and one family monopoly of power since independence.
Reply With Quote
  #103  
08-23-2012
Senior Member
 
: Apr 2011
: gwalior
: 53
:
: 711 | 0.18 Per Day
"Dirty game"

Gentle men ! "Once again politicians are going to play dirty game of reservation in promotion. Every body knows when a 40% obtainer gets the seat of boss in any department- what can we expect from him/her. This facts has no meaning to the politicians they mean only to divide our society and rule from graveyard. If politicians really mean to benefit public then let highest obtainer should be the boss or let the poor (below poverty line whom government has declared to distribute mobile) should be benefited with reservation."
Reply With Quote
  #104  
08-27-2012
Senior Member
 
: May 2012
: Mumbai
: 35
:
: 186 | 0.05 Per Day

gifts of reservation for India.
1 corruption (from above reply of members)
2 riots (in two different cast)
3 poverty (poor make poor and richer make rich)
4 illiteracy (some villages some lower cast not allowed for school )
this is the reality of my India.
i think we all are equal please all readers analysis that and think positive for all of us.
no cast no reservation we all are same.
Reply With Quote
  #105  
08-28-2012
Junior Member
 
: Aug 2012
: MAHARASHTRA
: 74
:
: 4 | 0.00 Per Day

To make a sweeping statement like ‘reservation is the root cause of corruption’ without any empirical evidence is rude, crude and weird. The founders of the Constitution thought deeply and deliberated the issue thoroughly for many years and finally included it in the Constitution for untouchables and Adiwasis who were badly in need of upliftment . Later on it became a political tool with advent of Mandal Commission and subsequent inclusion of OBCs into that list. Now Gujar Community has been agitating for S.T status. Rajasthan Government gave some reservation to the Gujar Community. Jat Community has been also agitating for reservation. In UP and Haryana they have been given some facilities. You mean to say that all these communities are corrupt and the remaining communities are honest? Read the old, medieval and modern history of India and find out for yourself, how untouchables and Adiwasis were treated in this country? What deprivation they have gone through? They were treated worse than animals. Don’t such people deserve reservation of not? We are allowing safai kamgars to carry night soil on their heads. Is it not inhuman? Despite ‘prevention of Atrocities against SCs and STs Act 1991, most brutal Atrocities are taking place against them. Don’t they deserve justice and fair play? and be brought into the main stream of the society? Otherwise, what remedies do you have to eradicate these worst evils afflicting our society? Don’t you realize caste and discrimination based on caste have been eating into the vitals of our country and obstructing its progress?
__________________
With Warm Regards,
N. RamaRao.
Reply With Quote
  #106  
08-28-2012
Junior Member
 
: Aug 2012
: Gurgaon
:
: 9 | 0.00 Per Day

Corruption does not come because of reservation but reservation comes out because of corruption!

I think the heading of the blog is a bit skewed and can not be generalised.

As I have said before, the idea behind reservation was a good idea but it was an imcomplete idea. It was not backed up by other laws that should have checked the reason for requiring the need for reservations.

Please see my comments on the other reservation related blog for more details.
Reply With Quote
  #107  
08-29-2012
Senior Member
 
: Apr 2011
: gwalior
: 53
:
: 711 | 0.18 Per Day
"my view"

To make a sweeping statement like ‘reservation is the root cause of corruption’ without any empirical evidence is rude, crude and weird. The founders of the Constitution thought deeply and deliberated the issue thoroughly for many years and finally included it in the Constitution for untouchables and Adiwasis who were badly in need of upliftment . Later on it became a political tool with advent of Mandal Commission and subsequent inclusion of OBCs into that list. Now Gujar Community has been agitating for S.T status. Rajasthan Government gave some reservation to the Gujar Community. Jat Community has been also agitating for reservation. In UP and Haryana they have been given some facilities. You mean to say that all these communities are corrupt and the remaining communities are honest? Read the old, medieval and modern history of India and find out for yourself, how untouchables and Adiwasis were treated in this country? What deprivation they have gone through? They were treated worse than animals. Don’t such people deserve reservation of not? We are allowing safai kamgars to carry night soil on their heads. Is it not inhuman? Despite ‘prevention of Atrocities against SCs and STs Act 1991, most brutal Atrocities are taking place against them. Don’t they deserve justice and fair play? and be brought into the main stream of the society? Otherwise, what remedies do you have to eradicate these worst evils afflicting our society? Don’t you realize caste and discrimination based on caste have been eating into the vitals of our country and obstructing its progress?
Gentle senior sir ! "My views are - "reservation is one of the root cause of corruption not ‘reservation is the root cause of corruption’. I have a logic behind it- This is the reservation that pussing intelligence behind in government sector- as 40% scorer get selected through reservation and get promoted early and reach the position of boss and a less skilled person can never make vital decisions which becomes the cause of government failure."
Further I am not against social uplift...............at present a person get a government job selected through reservation. The children of that person is being benifitted scholarship and fee concession later they easily take advantage of reservation and occupied another seat in government job. This practice is going since last 30 years onwards.....Now the person belonging to sc/st/obc who are below poverty line are neither getting better education nor getting job in government sectors.....Now question arise- For this kind of social uplift the constitutional bodies design the reservation plan..........................You are a senior one I respect senior by heart...........If you feel I am wrong then- visit road side that is being under construction and ask the workers(found there )which caste they belong to...............you are sure to have answer.........with best regards... sunil mishra gwalior

Last edited by sunil_mishra; 08-29-2012 at 01:33 PM
Reply With Quote
  #108  
09-04-2012
Junior Member
 
: Sep 2012
: Noida
: 45
:
: 3 | 0.00 Per Day

In My view when one process(Like reservation) implemented it should be matured as the time passes.

But what happened in india noone care about it so now all such implemented processes got absolete.

There are people who actully need resrvation but the challenge is how to find & facilitate them.
Reply With Quote
  #109  
09-09-2012
Senior Member
 
: Apr 2011
: gwalior
: 53
:
: 711 | 0.18 Per Day
"Promotion"

Gentle men ! "Government is keen to pass the bill that could bring reservation in promotion of SC/ST. When will the day come for the people who are working alongside the road as workers. When they found themselves uplifted by the government as they also have birth right of reservation."
Reply With Quote
  #110  
09-10-2012
Senior Member
 
: Apr 2011
: gwalior
: 53
:
: 711 | 0.18 Per Day
"Views"

Gentle men ! Gandhi Ji said, " Pichhade aur gareeb tabke ko aarakshad dene ki bajay unke liye aavas, shiksha, vyavsay aur rojar jaisi subdhaye pradan ki jay."
Rajeev Gandhi said,"Aarakshad dene ke peechhe aham swal yah hai ki kya sarkar mahaj rajneetik swartho ki vajah se hi ese lagoo karna chahti hai."

Above both statement declares, "There is no need of reservation. Even then we still are facing reservation since (1901-Sahu ji maharaj), (1921 Madras presidency......8%) (1950 free india.......sc 15%, st 7.5%), (1990 v.p. singh government....OBC 27%) it is increasing day by day. One more thing reservation in promotion has been given since 1955. Government is not giving preference even supreme court orders 1992,2006.

In 1991 Central Government had tried to provide 10% reservation to the poor belonging to general but it could not be implemented till today.....

Above all statics shows there is no mercy for the poor. No justice to the poor. No matter the poor belong to any category.

Last edited by sunil_mishra; 09-10-2012 at 04:31 PM
Reply With Quote




India Against Corruption
India Against Corruption is a PUBLIC Forum, NOT associated with any organisation(s).
DISCLAIMER: Members of public post content on this website. We hold no responsibility for the same. However, abuse may be reported to us.

Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0