Step up against the reservation system in India

Babusamuelp · #11 05-17-2011

I fully agree with you. There should not be any caste based reservation but reservation to financially backward people. I am also against providing promotions etc. on caste basis as it lowers the morale of lot of other senior official in the same concerns. This will definitely help millions of poor people of the so called upper caste people. Reservation based on financial background will include all poor people of all the caste and creeds.

sunil_mishra · #12 05-18-2011

every person can do anything. it is the way by which people think. can't a lower caste person think like any upper caste person? the difference is not in the caste, it is in the mind. even an lower caste person can think like or better or much much better than a upper caste person. wait a minute, what is a caste? difference in people? well i say the difference should be in the thoughts of people. all people are at the same levels. this law of caste should change. sorry if anyone thought bad of my message but i just wanted to see unity among ourselves. even before during the freedom struggle we lost a bit due to lack of unity. if we had unity among ourselves even before, we would not have needed to face the past struggle. well, past is past. we cannot change it. at least let us now be united. this is just my opinion. jai hind!

Dear ! This is the very first time when i can say that our future is in good hands. You are "The dream boy of great expectation". May God bless you and your thoughts."
"Reservation is a black magic of politician which do not let us united. In my opinion it is the time to oppose corruption first later i am sure to go against the reservation with my full strength."

Vinay Kumar · #13 05-18-2011

Yes, of course lower caste people can think better than upper caste people. We agree that lower caste people have become smarter than upper caste people. They are enjoying caste-based reservations and other benefits and advising general caste people to keep away from caste system. Our bespectacled children are burning their eyes for a quality study and these chaps enjoying and going ahead of hard working children from general category. Not only that, general category people are guiding them and doing everything to help them. Can this ice-cream jo jo dare to demand complete removal of caste-based reservation? Which part of history suggests that lower caste people have excelled over upper caste? We had given an opportunity to a SC chief minister Mayawati for a better governance. What she did? She went on a statue-installation spree of dalit icons all over the state spending nearly Rs 2000 crores. Her plan is to replace all the statues of upper caste great leaders with statues of dalits. Not on a single occasion she expressed worry about Bharat. We are sure she will oppose this name too because this is an Aryan name. General caste people are mute spectators. So, we can say lower caste people are smarter than upper caste people nowadays.

every person can do anything. it is the way by which people think. can't a lower caste person think like any upper caste person? the difference is not in the caste, it is in the mind. even an lower caste person can think like or better or much much better than a upper caste person. wait a minute, what is a caste? difference in people? well i say the difference should be in the thoughts of people. all people are at the same levels. this law of caste should change. sorry if anyone thought bad of my message but i just wanted to see unity among ourselves. even before during the freedom struggle we lost a bit due to lack of unity. if we had unity among ourselves even before, we would not have needed to face the past struggle. well, past is past. we cannot change it. at least let us now be united. this is just my opinion.
jai hind!

icecream7 · #14 05-19-2011

no pain no gain. this saying is equal on all the people. there should be no high and low castes in this country.
jai hind

sunil_mishra · #15 05-19-2011

no pain no gain. this saying is equal on all the people. there should be no high and low castes in this country.
jai hind

"Gentle Men ! Politician divides us as gen/sc/st/obc. An intelligent divides us as poor/middle class/rich. I divide our country people in between to group performer/dependent. Performers are always poor. As we can see many a persons working along roadside whom we call labourer. Can any one tell which category they do belong. What kind of reservation they are getting. What kind of facility they are getting from either side. They are only labourer by birth to death. The person who is unable to maintain his/her one day living, how could he/she be in the anty/supporting race of reservation. Means the person who is capable to reach upto level of achieving the facility of reservation, are getting anty of each others. Let us try to think like vinay kumar sir.............who is all time ready to keep on firing on the people getting advantage of reservation. He too is quite right as they are not worthy to get reservation and any facility given on account of cast base....Real sc/st/obc who are found along side of the raod or footpath, are not getting reservation facility. Unfortunately Shu Shri Mayabati is also avoiding them as they are not dalit they are poor and also giving more and more statue to dalit instead of living of a day(rozi roti). If we really want to uproot the reservation system then we have to make an aproach to reach upto really poor people.

Venkat D · #16 05-19-2011

Yes. Reservation should be done away with in a phased manner with immediate declaration of no reservation for OBCs and a comprehensive purpose-serving reservation for SC/ST for another 10years only in the domain of education but not in employment.

But for ever reservation based on economic status will help poor people a great deal and this will in the long run reduce the glaring disparity between haves and have nots.

Is there any politician who is prepared to accept this suggestion? Not one as I know of. Because politicians are too pusillanimous to call a spade a spade.

Public opinion should be raised in diverse fora and something rational may become a reality in distant future.

sunil_mishra · #17 05-20-2011

"Gentle men ! Yesterday our ho'nble prime minister has declared to count down the people living below poverty line. But saddest part of this counting is, it will be done castwise. No wonder ! Next announcement of our ho'nble prime minister will be castwise five year plan, castwise state, castwise railway station, banks, colleges etc.

**NCSinha** · #18 05-20-2011

Yes. Reservation should be done away with in a phased manner with immediate declaration of no reservation for OBCs and a comprehensive purpose-serving reservation for SC/ST for another 10years only in the domain of education but not in employment.

But for ever reservation based on economic status will help poor people a great deal and this will in the long run reduce the glaring disparity between haves and have nots.

Is there any politician who is prepared to accept this suggestion? Not one as I know of. Because politicians are too pusillanimous to call a spade a spade.

Public opinion should be raised in diverse fora and something rational may become a reality in distant future.

In phased manner! Even after 60 years of skewed policy of reservation, you want it to go in a phased manner? It won't then go even in another 100 years. Don't you know how we treat our time? One might ask you to wait for 5 minutes. Rest assured he will make you wait for hours. That is how we treat our time here in our country. We are all following the principle of phased manner. This has carried us this far and will take miles before it comes to a halt, i.e. if ever it decides to come to a halt at all.

Vinay Kumar · #19 05-20-2011

Now everybody (except privileged) has accepted that reservation system has become a cancer and treatment of cancer requires complete removal of infected cells. If a single cell remains there, it will multiply again. I fully agree with Sinha ji that we should not blow hot and cold. We should go for a single line- Abolish reservation system completely. I had asked for an information on a website if any country (under-developed, developing or developed ) has this kind of reservation system? So far, I have not come across any such system. The only viable solution to help poor is to give them free education, free uniforms and free meals. Please let me know if this offer is acceptable?

**NCSinha** · #20 05-20-2011

A mature nation is that which has a uniform policy for all citizens irrespective of sex, religion etc. The only exception, if any at all, is to be made to the physically handicapped. In fact, in most of the countries specific kinds of jobs are reserved for the physically disabled. As far as I know there is no country in the world that has the kind of reservation we in India have. You have the basic know-how, you get the job. No special treatment. That is why while most of the countries despite having got fewer resources have economically thrived and the distribution of wealth in those countries has been more equitable than in our own country. Just look at Japan. No reservation and yet how well galvanized their economy is that it is able to weather the shock of recent Tsunami. And Japan does not have a regular army like we have. Theirs is a mature nation that does not want reservation of any kind. There is no reservation even in the Islamic states. Give equal opportunity and respect to each of your citizen and job according to his or her expertise, the nation will progress. Else, we shall keep squabbling and reach no where. The recent cases of goof-ups by the officials of Ministry of Home Affairs while compiling the list of the most wanted and CBI moving on to a foreign land with an expired warrant, Foreign Minister reading out the speech of some other country in the UN and the prime minister alluding to India's role in Baluchistan in a joint statement issued by India and Pakistan can well be because of the reservation policy. Reservation creates a divide and those benefiting from it are a class apart who do not have to account for anything simply because they are here because of reservation.

Step up against the reservation system in India

I fully agree with you. There should not be any caste based reservation but reservation to financially backward people. I .....