India Against Corruption

Register

  India Against Corruption > ANTIRESERVATION FORUM > DISCUSSIONS on Reservation > Opinion
New Topics

My Views Against Reservation in India

raghvwidluv ji plz read the depak badigar's post, Yeh sahi hai ki kisi basti me ja kar waha k logo .....



37


  #71  
08-27-2011
Junior Member
 
: Aug 2011
: jaipur(rajasthan)
: 39
:
: 23 | 0.00 Per Day


raghvwidluv ji plz read the depak badigar's post,
Yeh sahi hai ki kisi basti me ja kar waha k logo ko dekho toh pata chalega ki reservation se unki condition achhi hoti hai, i agree but reservstion ks aadhar caste nahi, financial hons chahiye, taki gareebo ko bhi roti kapda or makan mil sake, par ek baat bataiye kya gareeb sirf pichadi caste me hi hote hai kya? Genral caste me nahi hote?
  #72  
08-27-2011
Member
 
: Aug 2011
: Hyderabad
:
: 87 | 0.02 Per Day

raghvwidluv ji plz read the depak badigar's post,
Yeh sahi hai ki kisi basti me ja kar waha k logo ko dekho toh pata chalega ki reservation se unki condition achhi hoti hai, i agree but reservstion ks aadhar caste nahi, financial hons chahiye, taki gareebo ko bhi roti kapda or makan mil sake, par ek baat bataiye kya gareeb sirf pichadi caste me hi hote hai kya? Genral caste me nahi hote?
Mr. Atreya,
Depak badigar haven't provided me any sources for his post... To know my views & opinions on reservations, you may need to read all or few of replies in this forums...
__________________
"Where can we go to find God if we cannot see Him in our own hearts and in every living being."

- Swami Vivekananda
  #73  
08-28-2011
Junior Member
 
: Aug 2011
: noida, up
: 48
:
: 6 | 0.00 Per Day

I agree that the reservation should be applicable on financial grounds but also consider that the idea of reservation is based on increasing particiaption of different sections of society in making of the nation and we have seen some good results as well.
Further I will say that one umbrella theory doesn't work well in realm of reservation, for example, in cities we don't see cast based discriminations generally so in such areas economical reservation is much more suited whereas in rural areas where people are facing discrimination based on case the reservation based on caste is suitable.
having said that, the actual implementation issues and need for thought arise, lets discuss it here and see what we gain out of it.
BR
Subs

Last edited by subodhkatiyar; 08-28-2011 at 04:41 AM : typo
  #74  
08-28-2011
Member
 
: Aug 2011
: Hyderabad
:
: 87 | 0.02 Per Day
Agree!

I agree that the reservation should be applicable on financial grounds but also consider that the idea of reservation is based on increasing particiaption of different sections of society in making of the nation and we have seen some good results as well.
Further I will say that one umbrella theory doesn't work well in realm of reservation, for example, in cities we don't see cast based discriminations generally so in such areas economical reservation is much more suited whereas in rural areas where people are facing discrimination based on case the reservation based on case is suitable.
having said that, the actual implementation issues and need for thought arise, lets discuss it here and see what we gain out of it.
BR
Subs
Very good points dude... I agree with you...
__________________
"Where can we go to find God if we cannot see Him in our own hearts and in every living being."

- Swami Vivekananda
  #75  
08-29-2011
Junior Member
 
: Aug 2011
: bhopal
:
: 9 | 0.00 Per Day

(A request from Un-born-baby to God)

Dear God,
As u know that my parents have just died in the hospital due to train accident, some good people have admitted me in hospital so that there should not be any problem to me. But as I reached here a lot of problem came. Some of them are as followes ---

1) Wether I sould be a boy or a girl ?

If I will born as a boy, I will get all the facility of roaming day n night which is not possible for girls due to her sexual security reasons ? If I will born as a girl, I will get all the facilities of ladies reservation in jobs, trains, buses wether some body else is in more need of that doesn’t matter.

Jawaab do : Wether I sould be a boy or a girl ?


2) What should be my name?
As I was only surviving baby from accident, the suggestions r as under --
hindu - Chamatkar, Muslim- Karismaa, Christian - Miracle ( and so on )

If I will be made any one of them, I m directly/indirectly not being in community of remaining others. U have promised me that u r making me only humen then why ye log mere uppar kaum ka thappa jabardasti lagaa rahe hai?

Jawaab do : Wether I should be a hindu or muslim or sikha or christian ?


3) What should be my surname/category of caste ?
upper ya middle ya lower
If I will be made any one of them, I m directly/indirectly not being in group of remaining others. U have promised me that mujhe kewal apani choice se/ apne interest se kaam karna hai aur wahi mera profession kahlayegaa, phir kyo ye log mere uppar pahle hi profession( i.e. brahmin hai to pujaa path, kshatriya hai to defence, vaishya hai to business aur khsudra hai to service) ka thappa jabardasti lagaa rahe hai?

Jawaab do : Wether I should be Brahmin or kshatriya or vaishya or khsudra ?

4) Wether I must be adopted by a rich person or poor person ?
If I will be adopted by any one of them, I m directly/indirectly not being in group of remaining other.
U have promised me that mujhe kewal apani choice se/ apne interest ke school me study karna hai aur wahi mera mind ko explore karke mujhe successful banayegaa. Lekin yahaa to ye log garib aadmi ko ( brilliant hone ke bawjood) full facility wale school me admission kyo nahi de rahe hai ?


I want to become only doctor for these mentally ill persons who are generating such descrimininations in there mind and helpind the currepted people to do more corruption by implementing devide and rule formulae.

I want birth in poor family becoz aamiroo ke bigde nawab banne se jyada achchha hai ki mai kichad ka kamal ban jaau.


God please send me in a “Descrimination-free and corruption-free world”.


  #76  
12-25-2011
commonman's Avatar
Junior Member
 
: Dec 2011
: pakistan,gdkw,dadww
:
: 7 | 0.00 Per Day
Smile India against reservation

ARE U WITHANNA......
Kalam and Digvijay are RSS agents for Congress / Nai Dunia?
नई दुनिया नाम के अखबार ने अन्ना हजारे और आरएसएस के नेता और विचारक रहे स्वर्गीय नानाजी देशमुख की एक 28 साल पुरानी तस्वीर छापी है जिसमें दोनों साथ में दिख रहे हैं। इस तस्वीर को देखकर कांग्रेस ने अन्ना को आरएसएस एजेंट बताया है। हम कुछ और तस्वीरें यहां दे रहे हैं जिनमें नानाजी देशमुख दिगविजय सिंह, मोतीलाल वोरा, एपीजे अब्दुल कलाम, मुलायम सिंह यादव, एनडी तिवारी और बलराम जाखड़ के साथ नजर आ रहे हैं। तो क्या ये सारे लोग आरएसएस के एजेंट हैं? यह इस अखबार के संपादक और कांग्रेसी चमचे आलोक मेहता की ओछी हरकत है और इसकी जितनी भी निंदा की जाए कम है। Congress has called Anna Hazare an agent of RSS - these pictures clearly show Former President APJ Adbul Kalam and Cong Leader Digvijaya Singh posing with Nanaji Deshmukh - will Congress or its stooge Alok Mehta, Editor of Nai Dunia dare to call them RSS agents now?



--





JOIN US


https://www.facebook.com/pages/India...44605118983530
  #77  
12-26-2011
Member
 
: Apr 2011
: Delhi
: 64
:
: 53 | 0.01 Per Day

like Hitler said
"we will keep lying till the people believe us"
  #78  
12-26-2011
Senior Member
 
: Aug 2011
: Kanpur UP
: 39
:
: 373 | 0.08 Per Day

Well said mam n cngress leaders r doing the same hamari sarkar ke dwara bnaya lokpal ek sakht lokpal hai
JAI HIND
  #79  
08-01-2012
Senior Member
 
: May 2012
: Mumbai
: 37
:
: 186 | 0.04 Per Day

I also agreed with all my friends thoughts which share here with us .really remarkable from each side. thank you.
  #80  
08-21-2012
Junior Member
 
: Jul 2012
: ludhiana
: 45
:
: 1 | 0.00 Per Day
reservation

well i think you all general catgories guys are fool you know there must be reservation in each and every field like in sports suppose cricket and for sc st category the short hit by a batsman must be considered 4 runs or 6 runs and for sc st category shoaib akhtar should not ball more than the speed of 80 n it applies to all bowlers and if the sc st batsman got out he must be given another chance india will always win what u all guys think?

 

Similar Threads for : My Views Against Reservation in India
Urgent need of reservation for women in India
Step up against the reservation system in India
Will reservation ever end in India?
Reservation in India – A brief history
Caste politics through reservation technique in India





India Against Corruption
India Against Corruption is a PUBLIC Forum, NOT associated with any organisation(s).
DISCLAIMER: Members of public post content on this website. We hold no responsibility for the same. However, abuse may be reported to us.

Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0